×

Current Affairs for 8 July 2025

Supreme Court building with reference to 1977 judgment on Election Commission powers in SIR challenge

In SIR challenge, Supreme Court refers to 1977 judgment on Election Commission’s powers

08-Jul-2025 05:38 PM

In a case challenging the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls in Bihar, the Supreme Court referred to its landmark 1977 judgment in M.S. Gill vs. Chief Election Commissioner. The court highlighted the limits and accountability of the Election Commission’s powers under Article 324 of the Constitution.

C:\Users\PC\Downloads\EPaper-International_08-07-2025_G8DEJRKHP.1.png

What is the SIR Dispute?

  • Opposition Allegation: The Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls could potentially disenfranchise marginalized communities in Bihar.

  • Petitioners’ Concern: Large-scale deletion or scrutiny without safeguards may violate the constitutional right to vote.

  • Election Commission’s Argument: The SIR is a legitimate administrative action to update and clean electoral rolls.

Article 324 – Powers of the Election Commission:

  • Article 324 grants the Election Commission (EC) the power of “superintendence, direction and control” of elections to Parliament, state legislatures, and offices of President and Vice-President.

  • This power is broad but not absolute.

The 1977 M.S. Gill Judgment: Key Takeaways

  • Context: The EC had cancelled the election to the Ferozepur Lok Sabha seat in 1977 due to mob violence. The decision was challenged.

  • SC’s Verdict: The EC was empowered to cancel the election and hold fresh polls, under Article 324.

  • But, Justice V.R. Krishna Iyer cautioned that:

“Article 324 does not exalt the Election Commission into a law unto itself… Unchecked power is alien to our system.”

  • EC must act within norms of fairness and legality. If it misuses discretion, the court can intervene.

  • The broad terms like “superintendence, direction and control” are not a license for constitutional despotism.

Constitutional and Legal Significance:

Checks and Balances:

  • Reinforces that even constitutional authorities like EC are accountable and subject to judicial review.

  • No functionary, even one protecting democracy, is above the Constitution.

Protection of Electoral Rights:

  • SC’s reference to M.S. Gill ensures that electoral processes remain inclusive, especially for the marginalized sections.

  • Electoral roll revision must not be arbitrary or exclusionary.

Electoral Reforms and Due Process:

  • Underscores the need for procedural safeguards during voter list revisions.

  • Electoral integrity must not come at the cost of disenfranchisement.

Implications Going Forward:

  • The SC’s mention of this case signals that the court will closely scrutinize EC’s actions in Bihar.

  • Sets the tone for balancing electoral integrity with constitutional morality.

  • Likely to spark wider discussions on electoral reforms, especially on:

    • Voter deletion processes

    • Inclusion of vulnerable groups

    • Role of technology and Aadhaar in elections

Conclusion:

The Supreme Court’s reference to the M.S. Gill case is a timely reminder that while the Election Commission is entrusted with great responsibilities, it must exercise its powers with transparency, accountability, and fairness. The ongoing SIR dispute will test the balance between administrative necessity and constitutional safeguards — central to the health of India’s electoral democracy.

UPSCMains Practice Question

Ques:While Article 324 of the Constitution vests wide powers in the Election Commission, such powers are not absolute and must be exercised within the boundaries of fairness and legality. In light of the recent Supreme Court observations during the Bihar Special Intensive Revision (SIR) case and the 1977 M.S. Gill judgment, critically examine the scope and limits of the Election Commission’s powers.

Current Affairs - July 2025

Current Affairs - 8 July 2025

08-Jul-2025 12:25 PM

1. In July 2025, which Indian boxer won the gold medal in the women’s 54kg category at the World Boxing Cup held in Astana?

(A) Nikhat Zareen

(B) Sakshi Chaudhary

(C) Lovlina Borgohain

(D) Simranjit Kaur


2. According to the World Bank’s “Spring 2025 Poverty and Equity Brief”, which country is the fourth most equal society in terms of wealth?

(A) China

(B) Norway

(C) India

(D) Japan


3. Who won the inaugural Neeraj Chopra Classic 2025 held in Bengaluru?

(A) Julius Yego

(B) Rumesh Pathirage

(C) Arshad Nadeem

(D) Neeraj Chopra


4. Which country became the first in the world to officially recognise the Taliban regime in Afghanistan in July 2025?

(A) Russia

(B) India

(C) Iran

(D) China


5. Who won two gold medals and set a new competition record at the Beijing 2025 Asian Para Archery Championships?

(A) Rakesh Kumar

(B) Harvinder Singh

(C) Vivek Chikara

(D) Jyoti Singh


6. Who flagged off the three trophies of the 134th Durand Cup in July 2025?

(A) Droupadi Murmu

(B) Rajnath Singh

(C) Anil Chauhan

(D) Narendra Modi


7. What is the name of the political party launched by Elon Musk in 2025?

(A) Future First Party

(B) America Party

(C) Liberty Front

(D) Free Nation Party


8. On which date is World Zoonoses Day observed recently?

(A) 03 July

(B) 04 July

(C) 05 July

(D) 06 July


9. PM Modi is the ___ foreign leader to receive the 'Order of the Republic of Trinidad & Tobago' award.

(A) Second

(B) Fourth

(C) Fifth

(D) First


10. What is the name of the project under which the National Biobank was launched in July 2025?

(A) Phenome India

(B) Genome Bharat

(C) GeneSuraksha

(D) BioHealth Bharat